06/12/2018

...

Development

...

Apologies on the confusion on who would do the work.
Thanks for the review

...

https://jira.opnfv.org/browse/BAROMETER-96

Additional clarification added / needed

...

https://gerrit.opnfv.org/gerrit/#/c/57807/

INTEL_PMU loading issue

...

https://gerrit.opnfv.org/gerrit/#/c/41405/

Rename -- Need to check with APEX

...

Did new contributors get added?

Yes!

...

Plugfest (Al Morton)

ETSI NFVI Testing group might be interested in using Barometer
Might use Barometer to collect metrics during API compliance testing
Would also like to use fault triggering code from one of the Barometer demos

Bring an interface down / up, etc…

06/05/2018

DMA team (Tomo) to present a demo of Local Agent collecting OpenStack metadata.

One of the features of the DMA project is to collect virtual infrastructure information from OpenStack and make it available to collectd so that metadata can be added to metrics / events.
Tomo gave a demo of Local Agent using OpenStack API to gather metadata information for use by Collectd.

Development

https://jira.opnfv.org/browse/BAROMETER-99

VM -- Names
Proposal

https://jira.opnfv.org/browse/BAROMETER-98

Variable defined

Installer Integration -- No_sdn - 6/15/18

Nomination of new contributors

Self Healing Sig

Use case templates about DMA project and local healing
What about 5 9’s
White paper on Barometer’s role in self-healing / availability
Originally discussed in Sydney
What should be included and what people care about
NEC, Verizon, etc…
Focus is HA.

Go over monitoring paper

Go with Confluence Wiki on Barometer home page

New dedicated resource for collectd.

Ryan McCabe (Red Hat)

05/29/2018

Barometer OS Summit

Feedback was good
Questions

Starting to use collectd, Barometer
What different plugins available? Turns out most are already in Barometer

Prometheus was mentioned -- Mostly about host to get data into Prometheus from collectd. Not necessarily replacing collectd.

Virt Plugin

3 missing variables.
Added to JIRA

Ovs-stats

Extended DPDK stats
JC to check

PMU Plugin Wiki updates
Al Morton

List of VES metrics meeting this week
Going to agree with Al that IPMI are important. What will we do with those on ETSI side?
Give feedback to Al on VES.

NFVI Monitoring White Paper

Create google doc
Start outline
Should cover why to monitor specific metrics / conditions, not just these are the things that are available to monitor.

Sunku --

Had a chat Sando - Paul
Call at end of week
Self healing Sig

List of projects (OPNFV, etc…, )
Sunku to e-mail...

05/22/2018

(MS3) Installer integration with OpenStack

3.0 Integration / nosdn deploy / run HC 6/15
3.1 deploy SDN / pass HC 6/29

PMU Plugin

Evaluating options

JIRA item to track virt plugin metric additions (gaps with ceilometer) -- https://jira.opnfv.org/browse/BAROMETER-98
JIRA item to track virt plugin VM name enhancements -- https://jira.opnfv.org/browse/BAROMETER-99
Ceilometer / Collectd parity

Can Ceilometer be replaced with collectd?
https://github.com/openstack/collectd-openstack-plugins

NFVI (OpenStack Services) monitoring

https://github.com/rochaporto/collectd-openstack

NFVI Monitoring Whitepaper -- https://jira.opnfv.org/browse/BAROMETER-97

How to collaborate? Google docs?

05/08/2018 --

Gambia release planning

Gambia release will concentrate on maintenance and support of plugins delivered in Fraser release.
Need to check on status of ovs-dpdk-stats, ovs-dpdk-events plugins
One or two features might be added -- TBD

Need code review of container build changes! Gerrit # -- 53805
Standards
VES
Prometheus

05/01/2018 --

Gambia Release -- traditional release

Need scenarios and deliverables defined by May 11

Gambia Additions

More information added to virt plugin?

Cpu pinning
NUMA node characteristics
What to do about (mostly) static information?

Additional plugins?

May need modification to RAS

MCElog might be incomplete
Looking at out of band platform hardware

Additional containers?
Ceilometer replacement?

How to get metadata?

Need code review of container build changes! Gerrit # -- 53805
Standards
VES
Prometheus

Interest in using Prometheus as polling engine / TSDB
Prometheus_collectd_exporter vs. Prometheus_node_exporter

04/24/2018 --

...

Gambia Release

Traditional, XCI, both?

Not clear on XCI requirements.
When do the tests need to be in place for XCI?

What are tentative development goals for the Gambia release?

...

RPMs / Container build

...

j/92950950555?pwd=K2tWZWovWXJWTmNuZHIxNGlZWkpHQT09 and IRC #opnfv-meeting.

Standing agenda items

TSC updates
CI status
Release updates
Action item review

Next meeting

The next meeting takes place on 11 Oct 2022, at 15h00 UTC (15h00 Ireland/Dublin).

Agenda

TSC updates
- There are some proposed changes the charter to remove the restrictions on membership composition.
CI status
- stable/moselle container jobs are not building/pushing; seems to be a timing issue, the job ran before the stable/moselle
Release updates
Action item review

2022 Meetings

04-Oct-22

TSC updates
CI status
Release updates
Action item review

20-Sept-22

TSC updates
- TSC elections are coming up; the active contributors list is available: https://wiki.anuket.io/x/NgLxAQ
  - PTLs can add additional contributors until September 29th.
- There will be an election for 2022 TSC Member Replacement Election, Cedric Ollivier
CI status
- Moselle container jobs are failing
Release updates
- M2 has been approved
- M3 is November 8th
- There was a brief discussion about having a community release manager instead of a LF staff release manager
  - More details will be shared next week about role/responsibility of a community release manager
Action item review
- (Emma) Check on Moselle job failures

13-Sep-22

TSC updates
- TSC elections are coming up; the active contributors list is available: https://wiki.anuket.io/x/NgLxAQ
- There will be an election to fill the vacant seat left by Cedric Ollivier; timeline TBD, must be run within 30 days of notification
CI status
- Moselle jobs container jobs are failing.
Release updates
- M2 has been pushed to September 20th
Action item review

06-Sep-22

TSC updates
CI status
- Moselle container jobs are failing
Release updates
- M2 is scheduled for Sept 13
Action item review

16-Aug-22

TSC updates
- A new docs project was proposed; scope needs to be clarified and some questions addressed
- No stable branches were created for moselle for barometer, vineperf or kuberef; Cedric pointed to the solution, and offered to do the final creation step.
CI status
- Moselle jobs exist but are failing because there is no moselle branch
Release updates
- M1 is completed (Barometer Nile Release Planning)
- M2 is September 13th (Nile Release Progress)
Action item review

19-Jul-22

TSC updates
- release retrospective took place; mostly regarding docs
CI status
- All jobs are passing
Release updates
- Release cycle starting August 2nd
- M1 is August 16th
Action item review

28-Jun-22

TSC updates
- CFP deadline for ONE summit is July 10th
CI status
- All jobs are passing
Release updates
Action item review

14-Jun-22

TSC updates
CI status
- Jobs seem to be working again
Release updates
- Moselle is almost over; branch cutting and job creation pending
- Nile kickoff has been pushed out to give people a chance to decompress and deal with any delays in Moselle.
Action item review

31-May-22

24-May-2022

TSC updates
- Topics are due for developer event in Porto
- There will be one virtual-only track
Release update
- Today is M4; no action needed - all high priority items are resolved
- TSC was asked to approve the milestone; there were no objections
Ci status
- All green, but nothing seems to have run recently; barometer-daily-lakelse has not run for over a month; barometer-daily-master has not run for 2 weeks

03-May-2022

CI status
- All green
Release update
- TSC approved M3 today

26-Apr-2022

TSC Updates
CI status
- All is green
Release updates
- M3 was push out by 2 weeks
Action item review

19-Apr-2022 (Cancelled)

TSC Updates
CI status
- All is green
Release updates
- M3 is April 19th
  - High priority Jira issues resolved (closed or assigned to future release)
  - Preliminary documentation completed (confirmed by DOCs team)
Action item review

12-Apr-2022

TSC Updates
CI status
- All is green
Release updates
Action item review

05-Apr-2022

TSC Updates
- Airship project is proposed for archiving
CI status
- Everything is green
Release updates
- M3 is mid-April
Action item review

22-Mar-2022

TSC Updates
CI status
- All is green: https://build.opnfv.org/ci/view/barometer/
Release updates
- M2 was today
Action item review

15-Mar-2022

TSC updates
- There was no TSC meeting today;
CI status
- All is green! https://build.opnfv.org/ci/view/barometer/
Release updates
- M2 is very soon
Action item review
- (Emma) Update release documentation (Jira)

08-Mar-2022

TSC updates
CI status
- All is green! https://build.opnfv.org/ci/view/barometer/
Release updates
- M2 is in 2 weeks
Action item review
- (Emma) Update release documentation

01-Mar-2022

TSC updates
CI status
- All is green! https://build.opnfv.org/ci/view/barometer/
Release updates
- Reminder from dmcbride to update documentation on what we're planning to do for the release.
- Plans should include CentOS Stream
- TODO(Emma) Update release documentation
Action item review

22-Feb-2022

TSC updates
- Not moving to gitlab for Moselle
CI status
- All green
Release updates
- Not much happening; may have to remove support for pmu-tools, since the packages are not building https://review.rdoproject.org/r/c/centos-opstools/pmu-tools/+/39016
Action item review

15-Feb-2022

TSC updates
- CLA and gitlab migration are under discussion
CI status
- Looks good
Release updates
- Moselle M2 is mid-March
Action item review
- Emma to update meeting time to 2 hours earlier

07-Feb-2022

TSC updates
- Gitlab migration was discussed
CI status
- Everything is working
Release updates
- Moselle M2 is mid March
Action item review
- Update meeting time – proposed to move it 2 hours earlier

25-Jan-2022

Release updates
- Moselle M1 is 01 Feb 2022
CI status
- All are green!
TSC updates
Standards updates
- it looks like it's been published
RA2 discussion
- Looking to add requirements for metrics in kubernetes
- Output for RA2 content on this is a set of requirements for metrics
- https://www.etsi.org/deliver/etsi_gs/NFV-TST/001_099/008/03.05.01_60/gs_NFV-TST008v030501p.pdf
- https://wiki.anuket.io/display/HOME/Monitoring%2C+Metrics+and+Events+Requirements+High+Level+List
- https://github.com/opnfv/barometer
- https://archive.fosdem.org/2020/schedule/event/do_you_really_see_whats_happening_on_your_nfv_infra/

18-Jan-2022

Release updates
- Moselle is kicking off
CI status
- All are green!
TSC updates
Standards updates

11-Jan-2022

cancelled

04-Jan-2022

Release updates
- Tasks complete for Lakelse M5
CI status
- All green, and Lakelse jobs are up
TSC updates
Standards updates

2021 Meetings

14-December-2021

Lakelse updates
- exception approved for barometer m5 until December 17th
CI status
- All green!
TSC updates
Standards updates

07-December-2021

Lakelse updates
- M4 has been achieved
- M5 is December 14:- need to complete release readiness tasks: https://jira.anuket.io/browse/BAROMETER-186
CI status
- All green
TSC updates
- 2022 TSC co-chairs have been elected: Beth Cohen and Gergely Csatari
- SPC election underway: 2022 TSC Member, Co-Chair, and SPC Representative Elections
Standards updates

30-November-2021

Lakelse Updates
- TSC approved M4
CI status
- Everything is passing!
TSC updates
- Elections are underway for TSC co-chairs: 2022 TSC Member, Co-Chair, and SPC Representative Elections
Standards updates
- The TST008 update is that the ETSI Editors contacted Al today to say that their editing process (on the approved text) has begun.

23-November-2021

Lakelse Updates
- Release will be early next year
CI status
- Everything is passing!
TSC updates
- Elections are underway for TSC co-chairs: 2022 TSC Member, Co-Chair, and SPC Representative Elections
Standards updates
- No comment; remote consensus process closed; Document number updated to NFV(21)000243, and it's now considered "done"; expected actions from editors to update style and references;

16-November-2021

Lakelse Updates
- M4 is up today, which applies to specification projects
- There was a discussion on moving the release schedule so Lakelse finishes later
CI status
- Everything is passing
TSC updates
- Elections are underway for TSC co-chairs: 2022 TSC Member, Co-Chair, and SPC Representative Elections
Standards updates

09-November-2021

Lakelse update
- M4 is next, which applies to specification projects only
CI status
- https://build.opnfv.org/ci/view/barometer/job/barometer-collectd-latest-docker-build-push-master/ - failing
- https://build.opnfv.org/ci/view/barometer/job/barometer-collectd-experimental-docker-build-push-master/ - failing

...

Standards

All the info we’re collecting will end up in analytic engines

Analytics processing tasks need info all the way down to the agent layer
Need to make sure there’s a measurement timestamp to provide context

Does test008 spec have the flexibility to talk about measurement of network interface using a particular VLAN tag?

Yes, scope parameter makes that possible
Scope must be conveyed with the measurements

...

VES

6.0 specs on the way (next week)

Multi-VM reqs

...

Compass support -- not for Gambia or Fraser?

Barometer will be supported in Gambia

...

HA scenario issues with build

A problem with OOO?
Fails every third build or so.
Will be looked at soon (next week)

...

Edge Cloud

Requirements

Categories
Use cases

Latency

Use cases where latency is critical
Example feedback loop?

What does lightweight mean in the context of edge telemetry?

04/17/2018 --

Spoke with DMA project team. They are ok with working in a separate container. They will swing back in a few weeks with a demo.
Standards with Al Morton

No updates

VES with Bryan Sullivan

Most work done by Goku
Bryan will update VES for latest release to make sure it works with everything
Plan is place to move items forward in Barometer

RPMs with Leif

Making progress

Func tests

Will not support Compass this cycle

Collectd pull requests

Used to be tracked on wiki
We need to track open pull requests and put them on Barometer development update page: https://wiki.opnfv.org/display/fastpath/Barometer+Development+Updates

Release

Gambia path or something else?
Which track do we follow?
Continuous delivery

Flexibility with milestones, since you establish them yourself?
Bryan doesn’t think we should do traditional path -- not enough resources
FCI could be a good thing if it marries VES and Barometer

Edge Cloud

What are the requirements?

Need categories
Always about latency for faults and metrics
Framework and edge computing use cases would be good

Is VES a good fit?

Good for cloud-native
What is a cloud? What value does opensource ecosystem get from:

Common telemetry date model
Consistent set of mechanisms by which data delivered to collector

How lightweight?

Less than 1% CPU, and 5% memory
Two VES encodings: C and Java
Goku: tokenized VES data structure
Overhead of data and complexity of stack
Go from binary XML to tokenized JSON
Current implementation is not lightweight but is “easy”
Use gzip, as it is natively available to HTTP stack (works out of box)

04/10/18 --

DMA Project discussion

Positive feedback on DMA proposal. Want to move forward.
Work should be done in a separate container.

Standards

Al has been reviewing Alok’s VES proposals. Found some VMWare specific items. Vendor-specific provisions are discouraged. Al to talk with Alok ;).
VES is starting to incorporate some TOSCA information.

Collectd

Emma suggested that all collectd PRs be from the same fork, Barometer, in order to make collectd aware of who the reviews are for.
Also, should have more Red Hat people reviewing collectd. Need to talk with local Red Hatters.

VES

Bryan returned. Wants to keep the VES agent development moving forward. Did not know about DDS messaging stuff in ONAP. However, see’s that Kafka is not set in stone. What to do at the edge.

General

Next week I will be out. Andrew Bays will run meeting.

04/03/18 --

...

DMA Project

...

Presentation given by Tomofumi Hayashi. Slides available on the wiki.

...

Major takeaways…

Run time reconfiguration of collectd. There were some questions as to whether this should be a feature of something like an Ansible playbook.
Topology annotation. Questions about security and what information would be included. It was stated that only infrastructure information would be annotated.
Data reduction and analysis at the edge.
DMA project should be an add-on. Might need to be able to “unwind” project in the future.

- c/barometer/+/73001 will hopefully address these, as the failures both appear to be due to an issue in systems/centos/8/build_base_machine.sh
TSC Updates
- 2022 TSC Member, Co-Chair, and SPC Representative Elections (Co-chair elections) are underway, nominations close on 12 Nov 2021
Standards updates
Thoth
- Action(Emma): Investigate collectd failures on POD-18

02-November-2021

Lakelse update
- M3 is 02 Nov 2021
- preliminary documentation needs to be completed
- Action(Emma) to provide docs Scott Steele
CI status
- https://build.opnfv.org/ci/view/barometer/job/barometer-collectd-latest-docker-build-push-master/ - failing
- https://build.opnfv.org/ci/view/barometer/job/barometer-collectd-experimental-docker-build-push-master/ - failing
  - Both are based on the same Dockerfile (IIRC), with different parameters, so the same fix will likely solve this.
  - The issue might also be in all containers, but rebuilding was not triggered for others recently
TSC Updates
- TSC election has concluded
Standards updates
- No comments so far from the remote consensus process
Thoth
- Action(Emma): Investigate collectd failures on POD-18

26-October-2021

Lakelse update
- M3 is 02 Nov 2021
- preliminary documentation needs to be completed
New release names announced
- Moselle
- Nile
CI status
- https://build.opnfv.org/ci/view/barometer/job/barometer-collectd-latest-docker-build-push-master/ - failing
- https://build.opnfv.org/ci/view/barometer/job/barometer-collectd-experimental-docker-build-push-master/ - failing
TSC Updates
- Nominations are closed and voting is underway for the 2022 TSC Member, Co-Chair, and SPC Representative Elections, will close on 29 Oct 2021
Standards updates
- Approval process has been started for ETSI NFV GS NFV-TST008ed351 - this remote consensus process lasts for 4 weeks, started yesterday, Monday, October 25.
Committer clean-up
- Done
Thoth
- Sridhar requested some help with collectd on POD-18, one instance of collectd was continually restarting and workload migrations aren't being triggered when CPU intensive workloads are run.
- Sridhar outlined a plan to generate workload metrics using GANs since there's a lack of data from large enough clouds.

19-October-2021

Lakelse update
- M3 is 02 Nov 2021
CI status
- https://build.opnfv.org/ci/view/barometer/job/barometer-collectd-latest-docker-build-push-master/ - failing
- https://build.opnfv.org/ci/view/barometer/job/barometer-collectd-experimental-docker-build-push-master/ - failing
TSC Updates
- Nominations are closed and voting is underway for the 2022 TSC Member, Co-Chair, and SPC Representative Elections, will close on 29 Oct 2021
Standards updates
- ETSI standard was approved at the working group level today; next step: remote consensus
Committer clean-up
- Review up for Aaron and Calin: https://gerrit.opnfv.org/gerrit/c/barometer/+/72964

12-October-2021

Lakelse update
- M3 is October 19th
CI status
- https://build.opnfv.org/ci/view/barometer/job/barometer-collectd-latest-docker-build-push-master/ - failing
- https://build.opnfv.org/ci/view/barometer/job/barometer-collectd-experimental-docker-build-push-master/ - failing
TSC Updates
- Nominations are open for the 2022 TSC Member, Co-Chair, and SPC Representative Elections, will close on 15 Oct 2021
Standards updates
Committer clean-up
- Review up for Aaron and Calin: https://gerrit.opnfv.org/gerrit/c/barometer/+/72964

05-October-2021

Lakelse update
- M3 is October 19th
CI status
- Everything is passing
TSC Updates
- Nominations are open for the 2022 TSC memberships
Standards updates
- No updates; latest meeting was post-poned
Committer clean-up
- Process for removing committers:- either a committer steps down voluntarily or can be removed by a 2/3 majority vote.
- Action(Emma) Reach out to Calin about stepping down

28-September-2021

Lakelse update
CI status
TSC Updates
- Nominations are open for the 2022 TSC memberships
Standards updates
- A complete working group review of the document is happening, then it will be submitted for full approval.
Committer clean-up
- Emma did not check the existing process
- Emma e-mailed Aaron about stepping down as a committer - he agreed
- Al e-mailed Maryam about stepping down as committer - she sadly agreed
- Action(Emma): Check the existing process for removing committers;
- Action(Emma) Reach out to Calin about stepping down

21-September-2021

Lakelse update
- M3 is 19 Oct 2021 (Lakelse Schedule)
Anuket container images
- Containers to be uploaded to anuket dockerhub
- https://gerrit.opnfv.org/gerrit/c/barometer/+/72916
Ci status
- Looking good
TSC updates
- Anuket Active Community Members - 2022 list needs review/update
- Nominations are open for 2022 TSC Member, Co-Chair, and SPC Representative Elections
- Release naming suggestions are open: Release Name Selection
Standards updates
- Some minor revision is needed
Committer clean-up
- https://gerrit.opnfv.org/gerrit/c/barometer/+/72915/1/INFO.yaml#34
- Action(Emma): Check the existing process for removing committers;
- Action(Al): ping Maryam to step down

31-August-2021

Lakelse updates
- Today is M2 - scope freeze
CI status
Standards updates
- The ETSI-NFV test working group accepted the contribution on storage!
AoB

24-August-2021

Lakelse updates
- Need to add Lakelse labels to Jira items
CI status
Standards updates
- Updated draft of TST-008 to include storage metrics
AoB

17-August-2021

Lakelse updates:
- M2 (scope freeze) is 31 Aug 2021
- Discussions/triaging/scoping of RA reqs into to Jira items is taking place in the Release meeting for the next 2 weeks.
Ci status
- No status change
Standards updates
- no status change
AoB

10-August-2021

Lakelse updates:
- M2 (scope freeze) is 31 Aug 2021
- Discussions/triaging/scoping of RA reqs into to Jira items is taking place in the Release meeting for the next 3 weeks.
Ci status
- Everything looks fine (some older jobs are failing, but that's nothing to worry about)
Standards updates
- No updates
AoB

03-August-2021

Lakelse updates:
- M2 (scope freeze) is 31 Aug 2021
- Discussions/triaging/scoping of RA reqs into to Jira items is taking place in the Release meeting for the next 4 weeks.
Ci status
- barometer-daily-master is working again!
Thoth, possible demo/collab, discussion on the weekly tech discuss and weekly AI/ML meeting.
- Thoth project got approved at this week's TSC!
AoB

13-Jul-2021

Announcement: Meetings are cancelled the next two weeks for vacation time
Lakelse updates:
- M2 (scope freeze) is 31 Aug 2021
Ci status: barometer-daily-master is mostly working; there's an issue in uploading the artifacts, I've logged a ticket to get it investigated.
Gitlab transition:
- ETA is mid-August
AI/ML project, possible demo/collab, discussion on the weekly tech discuss and weekly AI/ML meeting.
AoB

06-Jul-2021

Kali updates:
- Anuket Kali was released https://docs.opnfv.org/en/stable-kali/
Lakelse updates:
- M1 passed last week: Barometer Lakelse Release Planning document submitted
- M2 (scope freeze) is 31 Aug 2021
Ci status
- The barometer-daily-master job is stalled; Fixed - there was a temporary shutdown to troubleshoot another failure.
Barometer slack channel
Gitlab transition: When is it happening?
- Everyone needs a gitlab account to contribute to anuket on gitlab
- Can then get added to the gitlab.
- No definitive date yet for transitioning to gitlab.
- Open question on what permissions/roles need to be set up before transition
AI/ML project, possible demo/collab, discussion on the weekly tech discuss and weekly AI/ML meeting.
AoB

Older meetings

Table of Contents

...