Anuket Project

 One important aspect on building new and modern telecom infrastructure is to reduce energy costs which today comprise of almost ~40% of their CAPEX and with expansion of new 5G and Edge solutions in Enterprises and RAN it is expected to increase .

The biggest challenge exists as still today most of telecom infrastructure is designed for Busy hours and is not flexbiel enough to tune and optimize to give best compromise between performance and energy use . It is therefore Energy efficiency is becoming critical in all domains including Cloud infrastructure .

Energy Efficiency  (EE) is defined as "the relation between the useful output and energy consumption" by ITU-T L.1330 :cite:p:`itutl1330` for telecommunication networks and ETSI EN 303 471 :cite:p:`etsien303sp471` for NFV, the useful output being a metric which represents the capacity provided by the service whose energy efficiency is assessed.

As an example, the useful output of a traffic forwarding function can be the data volume forwarded (e.g., measured in Byte) and the assessment of its energy efficiency is then based on the ratio between this volume and the energy consumed for processing it (e.g., measured in Watt.hour) : Energy Efficicency (B/Wh) = Traffic Volume / Consumed Energy

The method for assessing energy efficiency depends on the service targeted and the objectives. For NFV, ETSI proposes a method for production environment in ETSI EN 303 471 :cite:p:`etsien303sp471` and another one for laboratory one in ETSI ES 203 539 :cite:p:`etsies203sp539` (which is a common work with ITU-T which published as ITU-T L.1361 :cite:p:`itutl1361`).

Whatever the method and the service, it requires the cloud infrastructure to provide some energy consumption metrics for different parts of the infrastructure hardware (server, CPU etc.) as included in :ref:`chapters/chapter04:internal performance measurement capabilities`. These metrics can be an amount of consumed energy (measured in Joule or Watt.hour) or a real-time power utilisation (measured in Watt or Joule/second) as proposed by DMTF Redfish DSP0268 2022.2 :cite:p:`dmtfredfish` which specifies metrics EnergykWh and PowerWatts for this purpose.

Some relevant information regarding NFV energy efficiency can also be found in Open RAN Technical Priority - Focus on Energy Efficiency (March 2022) :cite:p:`oranenergyeff` and QuEST Forum - NFV Workload Efficiency Whitepaper (October 2016) :cite:p:`questnfvwlenergyeff`.

Sustainability , green energy and optimizing the efficiency of Telecom Networks is key requirement for all current and ongoing Network transformations and it should be enabled on each layer of the Network stating from Hardware infrastructure , Cloud and CaaS Systems , Applications and above all use of Data and ML/AI to optimize the energy use in real time

The key aspect of Optimizing energy efficiency is to enable smart observability which means that KPI are available at each layer and further they can  be co-related across a closed loop system to intelligently monitor and optimize the energy use 

Energy Efficiency DomainsExampleKPI Metrics
Hardware New Hardware Layer innovations
Cloud domainSupport new features on energy saving measures in Cloud 
ML/AI and Data analytics

Intelligence and Orchestration 

Use if SMO , RIC and ML/AI based decisions 
Applications Telecom Applications refactoring 

3.11.1 Energy Savings in Hardware:

Hardware and Physical infrastructure has the biggest role in improving the Energy efficiency (EE) in Telecom systems  , all of the related power related KPI should be available in the  Hardware metrics defined 

It is also important to design the Cloud infrastructure considering the best permutations that gives the most optimum output from Energy perspective . As an example design a workload with maximum use of GPU and L1 Accelerators 

    • Use of GPU can enhanced energy efficiency through ML/AI
    • Use of DPU can optimize energy efficiency by offloading all infrastructure services mainly storage , networking and security .
    • Use of Optimal SIlicon and architectures e.g X86 vs ARM can deliver substantial cost savings
    • Use of High voltages e.g 380v DC to reduce overall Power efificinecy
    • Liquid cooling and other passive infrastructure innovations  

Table 3-8.1 Energy Monitoring shows possible performance measurement capabilities for the Hardware Infrastructure. These measurements or events should be collected and monitored by monitoring tools.

RefHardware Infrastructure CapabilityUnitDefinition/Notes
hardwaremon.001Host CPU usageWatt (Joule/s)Real-time electrical power used by the processor(s) of a node (1)
hardwaremon.002NIC ,Accelerator cards , Fan and Power supplies energy use Watt (Joule/s)Real-time electrical power used by the processor(s) of a node (1)
hardwaremon.003GPU energy useWatt (Joule/s)Real-time electrical power used by the GPU
hardwaremon.004DPU energy useWatt (Joule/s)Real-time electrical power used by the DPU
hardwaremon.005eASIC energy useWatt (Joule/s)Real-time electrical power used by the eASIC

Table 3-8.1 Energy Optimization possible performance measurement capabilities for the Hardware Infrastructure. 

RefHardware Infrastructure CapabilityUnitDefinition/Notes

C-states  i.e C-0 ,C-1 ,C-2 ,TC-Custom availability 

Real-time electrical power used by the processor(s) of a node (1)
hardwareopt.002Capability to free up and control sleep mode/C-state/P-state of specific hardware resources (e.g.
server, CPU) 

dynamic reallocation of active workload to specific accelerators and/or CPUs

3.11.2 Energy Savings in Cloud layer:

As Telco's Cloud infrastructure will comprise of multi clouds and  different permutations on VIM and CaaS Layers it becomes important that the Cloud management solutions make best use of Energy efficiency measures provided by the hardware and ensures a optimally balanced  infrastructure.

Following are the main characteristics  from Cloud management layer to improve energy efficiency  

    • Cloud architecture  supports optimum load balancing 
    • Cloud layer supports resource optimization by adequately report the under utilized infrastructure 
    • Cloud supports the elastic and efficient shutdown of spare and un-used infrastructure ,  one key characteristic is abstract the physical resources from the application 

Internal Performance Measurement Capabilities

Table 3-8.2 shows possible performance measurement capabilities for the Hardware Infrastructure. These measurements or events should be collected and monitored by monitoring tools.

RefCloud Infrastructure CapabilityUnitDefinition/Notes
cloud.001VM and Container energy use Watt (Joule/s)Real-time electrical power aggregated at VM or Container level
cloud.002NFVI energy useWatt (Joule/s)Real-time electrical power aggregated at NFVI level
cloud.003Load balancing across all cloud resources Equal %Load balance across cloud infastructure
cloud.004Support for all energy KPI to NBI and OSS systesm-Integrate to NBI systems
cloud.005Indirect power reduction by means of energy aware traffic steering


Software sustainability

check @chris wright HOL for this

3.11.3 Energy Savings through Orchestration and Intelligence:

Internal Performance Measurement Capabilities

Table 3-8.2 shows possible performance measurement capabilities for the Orchestration and Intelligence Layer 

RefOrchestration and Intelligence CapabilityUnitDefinition/Notes
orchestration.001Data collection and visibility for all Energy KPI in real time 
Infrastructure should enable  new data architectures and orchestration capabilities 
cloud.002Real time tuning of  hardware 



3.11.4 Energy Savings in Applications:

Most of the Telecom applications currently are seldom designed by keeping energy KPI's and measures in place . With 5G Release17 there had been a lot of work and emphasis on Energy optimizations as can be refereed  in 

Table 3-8.2 shows possible 3GPP work on Energy Efficiency

3GPP TS 28.301Energy Efficiency of 5G systems
3GPP TS 28.5525G Performance Measurements
3GPP TS 28.813New aspects of Energy Efficiency for 5G

Table 3-8.2 shows possible performance measurement capabilities for the applications

RefCloud Infrastructure CapabilityUnitDefinition/Notes
app.001Host CPU usageWatt (Joule/s)Real-time electrical power used by the processor(s) of a node (1)
app.002VNFC level Energy utilizationWatt (Joule/s)
app.003VNF level Energy utilizationWatt (Joule/s)
app.002Network slice EE KPIperformance of slice /Wattas defined in 3GPP TS28.310
app.003eMBB slice EE KPIGbps /Wattas defined in 3GPP TS28.310


  • No labels